Character Topic 2:Ed Edd n Eddy

Maybe we could put in Ed Edd n Eddy from the popular tv series of the same name

As much as I would love the idea to "Can-Opener Man" someone, I say no random cartoon characters in Nuke. (I know Ed, Edd 'n Eddy is popular, but it's random to have the Eds in a game filled with famous video game fighters mostly from Nintendo.)
And no three in one character other than Pokemon Trainer.

Well I was thinking that the three eds would have their own character select without pressing the D-button

Gregboy101 wrote:

Well I was thinking that the three eds would have their own character select without pressing the D-button

We don't have space for unlimited characters, let alone gimmick "wtf" characters like the three Eds. If we did include them, it would likely be an unpopular choice, as a lot of people whose favourite characters were not included would likely feel like their choice had been replaced by three practically identical characters.

well what makes you say that?

Aside from that, if it can't handle two Ice Climbers, it can't handle THREE Eds.

look, can we just give them their own character select boxes, they don't have to be together when played

So you're saying have them as three separate characters?
No.
I doubt ANY Newcoming series will get more than character. Smash Bros. made it that way (with Roy being the only exception). And for Nuke, I hope it stays. (i.e. no Sephiroth, Black Mage, etc. since Cloud is in.)

But it will make the game more popular, what makes you think its a bad idea

Because Smash Bros. is supposed to be about VIDEO GAME characters.
Nintendo characters specifically, but with the addition of Sonic and Snake in Brawl, 3rd party characters have been expected. Nuke is carrying on the tradition.
Ed, Edd 'n Eddy is a cartoon. That's not even made by Nintendo. Why not add Chuck Norris while we're at it?
Rayman, I can understand. He's a famous video game character. The Ed's? No. Cartoon.

Well Greg Mcleod added characters from Inuyasha and Naruto, so they are cartoons

Gregboy101 wrote:

Well Greg Mcleod added characters from Inuyasha and Naruto, so they are cartoons

We aren't Mcleod. We put a lot of thought into the characters we choose to be in this game, and we don't just go "HEY KNOW WHAT WOULD BE COOL? *add character*". We did do that for the older version of the game, and it didn't turn out well. Each character has been thoroughly assessed with lots of criteria, not just who we want to see, but who others want to see, and how well they can work in the game, how they can be made balanced, and how they can work in original ways to make the game interesting.

Wait a minute are you saying you putted he eds in when the game was being made before?

1) Stop with this noobish idea. It's a SSB-based game, so Nintendo characters and some 3rd Party characters.
2) Cleod has no idea of what to do considering his game loses popularity by the minute and his game will lose to this one, as it has already.
3) Go make that as an expansion for SSF2, then, if you really want them.

Hence why secretive forums are the best. You don't have to deal with noobs.

But I don't know how to do that, plus it's also extremely hard to edit sprites

We didn't have the Eds in before, but we had other characters that were just as equally ridiculous. The best example of which was probably Cheese the Chao. In an older version of SNBM, Cheese was playable, but underpowered, boring, and hopeless.

Plus, I think you can get sprites of the Eds on the internet anyway, I'm sure I've seen some before.

Well I do have the sprites, but when save a picture on my laptop, it comes as jpg, So I am stuck with the compter in my room for no jpg, still it's hard to edit sprites

Corka Cola wrote:

1) Stop with this noobish idea. It's a SSB-based game, so Nintendo characters and some 3rd Party characters.
2) Cleod has no idea of what to do considering his game loses popularity by the minute and his game will lose to this one, as it has already.

I agree with 1), but 2) is false.
SSF2 is admittedly more hyped than Nuke. (Probably because it's been advertised more.)
The reason why it's more hyped, is because unlike SSF1, SSF2 is REALLY close to Brawl in terms of movesets. Nuke doesn't have all of the movesets, but what it does have, is handmade characters rather than a bunch a sprites that look out of place when put together. Because they are handmade, it takes more work, and is more admirable, as well as the end result being more desireable.

I say this, simply because I am hyped for both. Please don't flame me for wanting to play SSF2, because I want to play Nuke too. (I want to play almost every fanmade Smash Bros.)

Alright to be honest, I have know idea what that has to do with any of this?

Gregboy101 wrote:

Alright to be honest, I have know idea what that has to do with any of this?

That's because I wasn't talking to you. When you see a quote, it means I'm talking directly to someone, and that someone alone is supposed to read it.
However, if someone wants to add a point to that particular discussion, they can quote the quoter.

GoldenYuiitusin wrote:

Corka Cola wrote:

1) Stop with this noobish idea. It's a SSB-based game, so Nintendo characters and some 3rd Party characters.
2) Cleod has no idea of what to do considering his game loses popularity by the minute and his game will lose to this one, as it has already.

I agree with 1), but 2) is false.
SSF2 is admittedly more hyped than Nuke. (Probably because it's been advertised more.)
The reason why it's more hyped, is because unlike SSF1, SSF2 is REALLY close to Brawl in terms of movesets. Nuke doesn't have all of the movesets, but what it does have, is handmade characters rather than a bunch a sprites that look out of place when put together. Because they are handmade, it takes more work, and is more admirable, as well as the end result being more desireable.

I say this, simply because I am hyped for both. Please don't flame me for wanting to play SSF2, because I want to play Nuke too. (I want to play almost every fanmade Smash Bros.)

I agree with you on the fact that I play many SSB fangames, but the problem is is that right now, I have only seen three good ones, SSF, SSF2, and SNBM. This game is definitely the cleanest and am looking forward to more. Because some of them are crap, people flock to the biggest community, which is MG. Their forums have been devastated by noobs and have had many vets leave because of it. I have been around their network for about a year now to notice it.

Corka Cola wrote:

GoldenYuiitusin wrote:

Corka Cola wrote:

1) Stop with this noobish idea. It's a SSB-based game, so Nintendo characters and some 3rd Party characters.
2) Cleod has no idea of what to do considering his game loses popularity by the minute and his game will lose to this one, as it has already.

I agree with 1), but 2) is false.
SSF2 is admittedly more hyped than Nuke. (Probably because it's been advertised more.)
The reason why it's more hyped, is because unlike SSF1, SSF2 is REALLY close to Brawl in terms of movesets. Nuke doesn't have all of the movesets, but what it does have, is handmade characters rather than a bunch a sprites that look out of place when put together. Because they are handmade, it takes more work, and is more admirable, as well as the end result being more desireable.

I say this, simply because I am hyped for both. Please don't flame me for wanting to play SSF2, because I want to play Nuke too. (I want to play almost every fanmade Smash Bros.)

I agree with you on the fact that I play many SSB fangames, but the problem is is that right now, I have only seen three good ones, SSF, SSF2, and SNBM. This game is definitely the cleanest and am looking forward to more. Because some of them are crap, people flock to the biggest community, which is MG. Their forums have been devastated by noobs and have had many vets leave because of it. I have been around their network for about a year now to notice it.

Well, SSF was good for it's time, then as the years went by, people realized it was crap. SSF2 is a lot better.

Agreed. Are you on any other forums?

Corka Cola wrote:

Agreed. Are you on any other forums?

Glitch City Laboratories as "Chaos Hiruko".

Oh, you reminded me of a few people on the Expansions Forums when I did contribute. I was just wondering.

Back on topic or lock?